Jalsaghar And The Disciple- Two Austere Character Studies With A Spiritual And Philosophical Purity

By Aryan Vyas

There’s little doubt that these are arduous occasions. And it’s throughout such difficult occasions that we resort to artwork that’s made to complement the soul. As the brand new 12 months is upon us, I revisited one in all my high favourite movies from the previous year- Chaitanya Tamhane’s “The Disciple”. Quickly upon rewatching, I used to be sure that it was among the finest character research I had watched shortly. Fortunately across the identical time, as a tribute to 100 years of Satyajit Ray’s cinema, Amazon Prime began streaming a bunch of the legendary artist’s work on their platform. It didn’t take me lengthy to appreciate that Ray’s 1958 movie, “Jalsaghar (The Music Room)”, had develop into my favourite film of his. What blew my thoughts additional, is once I realized that Ray had made the movie simply after “Aparajito”, earlier than he went onto directing the becoming finale to probably the most influential and important movie trilogies of all time. I’ve all the time felt that there’s two elements to watching a film. The one the place you actively sit to look at the actual movie, and the latter one the place these photographs proceed to play in your head lengthy after the credit roll. Naturally, I began drawing parallels between these two titles, which revolve round Indian classical music, every telling the story of a person fading into the feudalism of it. 

Watch This Title
on Amazon

In “Jalsaghar”, we observe an impoverished landlord (Zamindar), Bishwambhar Roy (Biswas) spending the top of his days on his property, not becoming a member of in on life exterior of it. Tamhane’s sophomore movie however, tells the story of a struggling artist, Sharad Nerulkar who’s looking for his place on this planet however simply isn’t ok. Each of those pristinely crafted character research have one main factor in frequent on floor: characters obsessing over music and descending into it. However in the event you look carefully, these are multifaceted characters who’re coming to phrases with their private frustration, bitterness and failure. 

Each”Jalsaghar” and “The Disciple” standout among the many tons of of overwrought Indian musical melodramas we are likely to churn out yearly, due to how simple these tales are. Their magic stems out of the mundane of the characters at middle. Ray and Tamhane intentionally determined to not forged main skilled actors for almost all of the elements. It additionally appeared important to the administrators to not have music or dancing as mere decorum inside their image, however moderately make them core options of the plot and/or the characters of the movie. 

Whereas Satyajit Ray’s method of telling the story emphasised extra on slowly panning the digital camera into the faces of characters every time required to hit dwelling the feelings, Chaitanya Tamhane together with the DOP Michal Sobocinski shot many of the motion in austere head-on, long-held pictures. The quiet colours gave “The Disciple” a glance that was as pure and unfiltered as attainable. Each the movies have extraordinarily melancholic endings that don’t give us straightforward solutions and make us ponder. 

Satyajit Ray was recognized for the usage of all kinds of metaphors all through his filmography, with probably the most notable one being the usage of trains all through “The Apu Trilogy” throughout publish British rule in India, showcasing a way of the technological shift in course of. At some extent in “The Disciple”, the story flashes ahead a number of years. Each the movies present such speedy technological inflow by use of their beautiful imagery, at factors conveying the anguish and the frustration within the central characters’ minds, by way of such cleverly included metaphors. However that is by no means carried out in a head-on method; each administrators grasp the artwork of movie grammar which displays of their work. As an example, Sharad’s previous cassettes could also be outdated ’80s expertise, however they’re additionally technique of preserving and fascinating with a timeless artwork kind. 

In actual fact, in an article for the LA Occasions, movie critic Justin Chang even in contrast Tamhane’s use of visible storytelling to that of Satyajit Ray’s. “Jalsaghar” had probably the most evocative opening sequences ever put in a movie (rightly noticed by the late critic Roger Ebert and my favourite opening sequence). The chandelier is used to replicate Huzur’s way of thinking within the movie all through its runtime. Such observant particulars are the traits of an awesome storyteller. 

On the New York Movie Pageant in 1970, Ray was requested why he was now transferring his digital camera greater than within the Apu trilogy. “As a result of I can afford the gear,” he replied with a smile. Being the primary movie to extensively incorporate classical Indian music and dancing, “Jalsaghar” was additionally voted #20 on the listing of “100 Greatest Movies” by the outstanding French journal ‘Cahiers du Cinema’ in 2008. It additionally appeared on Roger Ebert’s “Nice Films” listing. “The Disciple” however, was one of many best-received entries ultimately 12 months’s Venice, Toronto and New York movie festivals (and the winner for screenplay prize at Venice). It solidified Tamhane’s title globally as probably the most outstanding younger filmmakers on the market. 

Much like Charles Foster Kane in Orson Welles’ “Citizen Kane”, Lord Roy in “Jalsaghar” sits on the high of his property when his servant brings his hookah, a lonely emperor who has develop into the fabric for legends amongst his topics. There are additionally related scenes in each the flicks that illustrate how little these characters now seem in entrance of their room home windows and mirrors; their loneliness is heightened because of such visible decisions portraying their loosening grip over their particular person relevance. “The Disciple” makes us surprise what it means to really be a real artist. There’s a nuanced distinction between topic and the story; these movies should not on Indian classical music per se, however moderately the visceral world that surrounds. There’s nobody who couldn’t relate to the themes of acceptance, succession and obsession or be tormented by the worry of mediocrity. However on the coronary heart of it, each the movies ask one main query: How can we discover our voice by shedding our personal?



  • Try your lucky to get discount coupon
  • 1 spin per email
  • No cheating
Try Your Lucky
Remind later
No thanks