Film review: From Up on Poppy Hill (2011) by Goro Miyazaki

A captivating take a look at Studio Ghibli getting ready to transition

Hayao Miyazaki — simply essentially the most recognizable face behind Studio Ghibli — has lengthy mentioned that he would retire. Since then, all eyes have turned to his first son and inheritor, Goro Miyazaki. Goro Miyazaki appears to chafe underneath his father’s strictly conventional methods; his most up-to-date launch, “Earwig and the Witch” (2020) made a splash alongside Cannes headlines for being the primary CGI movie produced by the largely paper-and-paint-based studio. In flip, his earlier work “From up on Poppy Hill” seems like an externalization of Goro’s inner wrestle. Modernity and custom collide once more on this postwar port metropolis, the place a single government transfer may tear down a historic constructing. It takes the whole thing of a faculty to salvage what may in any other case be erased without end. 

Purchase This Title

As per each different Ghibli movie, “From Up on Poppy Hill” follows a younger feminine protagonist. In 1963 Yokohama, Umi Matsuzaki (Masami Nagasawa) is broadly thought of as a “good woman.” She cooks, she cleans, dutifully goes to highschool, and takes care of her grandmother’s boarding home. Nevertheless, when she locks eyes with the Shun Kazama (Jun’ichi Okada) — the college insurgent, stud, and activist all-in-one — she finds herself thrown right into a school-wide undertaking to protect the native clubhouse. All of it involves a shuddering halt, nevertheless, when she finds out that Shun is likely to be her long-lost brother as a substitute. 

At first look, this movie recollects an earlier Ghibli work, “Ocean Waves” (1993) – one other highschool romance animated by a youthful faction of Studio Ghibli. Nevertheless, right here in “Poppy Hill,” one can undoubtedly discover the price range improve. The characters swoon and sigh at the next body charge, enjoyable with a degree of ease not possible with the older TV film. There’s a looser connection to contemporaneity, as nicely. Not like “Ocean Waves”’ attribute retro tinkle of the late 80s-90s, composer Satoshi Takebe indulges at school songs, choral items, and navy tunes. He appears extra bent to explain the characters’ angle than he’s to the occasions. This dissonance factors to the characters’ distance from chaotic Tokyo as nicely — which is, historically-speaking, most likely elevating all hell within the title of the Olympics.

Furthermore, whereas “Ocean Waves” dripped with need, “Poppy Hill” cuts any romance brief. Umi is just too simple to take care of any sexual stress. Like every other character Hayao writes, she straight addresses something throughout the realm of the unknown; she instructions the display screen via her phrases relatively than her magnificence. This makes Umi, our plain-faced protagonist, appear much more bland on the silver-screen. Maybe that is the actual cause why Hayao was by no means well-known for his lovelorn heroines; he merely couldn’t dictate the refineries of romance. 

Goro’s heavy hand leaves Umi’s character growth wanting, as nicely. For all of Umi’s steadfast down-to-earth-edness, she nonetheless pales compared to Shun. That is most evident within the clubhouse, when the boys get carried off of their wild innovations whereas the ladies merely… clear. Although Umi does obtain credit score over and over for her personal modern options, she merely doesn’t have enjoyable. A lot to Umi’s detriment, this nearly reads extra as Shun’s story relatively than Umi’s. 

Apart from this, nevertheless, the movie continues to be a magnificence to put one’s eyes upon. The units are nonetheless as painstakingly painted as every other Ghibli movie. The viewer can feast upon the clubhouse, which options the usual Ghibli muddle: mud and small rodents and heaps upon heaps of kerfuffle. Goro makes certain so as to add in an mouth-watering kitchen scene (this time, the menu is fish tempura) and town vistas are merely breathtaking. This alone might justify its smattering of prizes. On the time of its launch, the function received the Tokyo Anime Award (2012), Japanese Academy Finest Animation Award (2012), and the Annie Award nomination for writing (2013).

In reflection, “Poppy Hill” is gorgeous, however extra boring than anticipated. It might be good to see Goro Miyazaki have interaction in tales that really resonate with him, relatively than to comply with his father’s script (or footsteps). In any case, we already start to see extra of his rebellious tendencies pre-CGI by notably co-opting the Robust Impartial Girl’s story right into a enjoyable boy’s sport. Just like the proverbial clubhouse, it’s only a matter of time till we see Studio Ghibli fully change too from inside out.

TagsDigicam Japan From Up On Poppy Hill Goro Miyazaki hayao miyazaki Junichi Okada Masami Nagasawa Satoshi Takebe Studio Ghibli



  • Try your lucky to get discount coupon
  • 1 spin per email
  • No cheating
Try Your Lucky
Remind later
No thanks